10 Best Sephora Mascaras of December 2025

List of Top Rated Sephora Mascaras from thousands of customer reviews & feedback.

Updated On Dec 2025

1,731 Reviews Studied

By Customer Ratings

2
Image
Sephora Collection Outrageous Extension Dramatic Volume & Length Mascara Full Size 15 ml 0.5 Fl oz Read Review

  • The first Sephora Collection mascara that instantly volumises and lengthens lashes!
  • Thanks to the perfect combination of a formula enriched with keratin, intense black and an exclusive elastomer brush, this mascara is the only one in the Sephora range that gives such a volume and elongation effect.
  • An unusual brush with conical needles extends the lashes without leaving lumps.
  • The formula enriched with keratin wonderfully thickens and strengthens eyelashes.

3
Image
Sephora Collection Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover, 6.76 oz. Read Review

  • Instantly removes eye makeup, even waterproof, without any greasy effect.

5
Image
Sephora Collection LashCraft Big Volume Mascara - .18 oz Mini Read Review

  • .18 oz. Mini - measures approximately 4" high
  • A full-volume, intensely pigmented mascara
  • Cruelty-free

6
Image
Sephora Lashcraft Lash Primer Mascara Base Full Size Read Review

  • SEPHORA LASHCRAFT LASH PRIMER MASCARA BASE: A high-performance lash primer to prime, plump, and enhance the appearance of lashes while extending the wear of mascara.LASH CRAFT - Mascara Lash Primer FULL SIZE - 0.3 oz / 9ml
  • REAL LIFE, MEANS REAL RESULTS: LashCraft Lash Primer prevents flaking and smudging of any mascara formula. It goes on white but dries translucent, allowing you to achieve va-va-voom volume and thicker, fuller lashes.
  • SEPHORA DELIVERS: Sephora is dedicated to creating products that give you results and that give you the look you are looking for.
  • INGREDIENTS THAT WORK: Sephora is dedicated to creating new and innovated beauty product with using cruelty free and clean ingredients. MADE IN FRANCE
  • APPLICATION PROCESS: -Apply directly to clean lashes, coating them from root to tip. -Apply traditional mascara over the LashCraft Lash Primer while the lash primer is still wet on the lashes.

7
Image
Sephora Lashcraft Big Extreme Volume Mascara Noir 01 Black Full Size Read Review

  • Lashcraft Big Extreme Volume Mascara
  • Lengthens and Volumizes Eyelashes - starting at base wiggle mascara wand through eyelashes for maximum volume
  • SHADE: 01 Noir Black
  • Full Size
  • MADE IN CANADA

8
Image
SEPHORA COLLECTION Outrageous Volume Mascara Ultra Black Read Review

  • Outrageous Volume Mascara delivers extreme volume for lashes with a triple-reserve brush
  • tested under ophthalmological control and are suitable for sensitive eyes and contact-lens wearers.
  • Size : 0.5 oz (full size)
  • Color : Ultra Black

9
Image
Sephora Collection SIZE UP Mascara Immediate Supersized Volume 01 Ultra Black 14 ml 0.47 fl.oz Read Review

  • Mascara for eyelashes from SEPHORA COLLECTION, which provides instant volume combined with the effect of elongation and curling, all in just one stroke.
  • What kind of makeup? From everyday to evening wear.
  • Size Up gives the effect of plump lashes: + 180% * of the volume after a few mascara strokes
  • Differences: Vegan ** and long-lasting formula enriched with microspheres in combination with an hourglass-shaped brush provides an immediate volume effect. In the middle, the short bristles allow intense coverage of the eyelashes for extreme and extremely black volume.
  • - Start painting the eyelashes from their roots - You will comb them at the roots in a zigzag movement several times - Apply the mascara until you get the volume you want

10
Image
Sephora Collection Outrageous Oversized Lashes Ultra Black 15 ml 0.5 fl oz Read Review

  • Mascara for increasing the volume of eyelashes SEPHORA COLLECTION: XXL volume, 3D effect
  • The mascara has a properly profiled wand and a multidimensional black formula that visibly thickens, lengthens and emphasizes the beauty of the eyelashes.
  • Hourglass shaped spiral for XXL volume
  • 3D effect: thicker, longer and evenly brushed lashes.
  • The right amount of mascara for beautifully defined eyelashes.