10 Best Penny Loafers of March 2025

List of Top Rated Penny Loafers from thousands of customer reviews & feedback.

Updated On Mar 2025

669 Reviews Studied

By Customer Ratings

1
Image
Eastland Women's Classic II, Black, 8 M US Read Review

  • Featured in navy leather
  • Hand sewn constuction
  • Lightweight rubber outsole
  • Imported

2
Image
Cole Haan Men's Howland Penny Loafer, Saddle Tan, 11 M US Read Review

  • Penny loafer in vintage-finish leather featuring moccasin stitching and split pod sole with driving heel
  • Perforated arch support
  • Fit Tip: Sizing runs small. We recommend ordering a half size up. ; Calfskin upper ; Contrast stitch and signature hardware detail at the heel.

3
Image
Rockport mens Classic Penny Loafer, Black/Black, 10.5 M US Read Review

  • Adiprene provides shock absorbing heel cushioning with resilient forefoot cushioning
  • Ethyl vinyl acetate footbed conforms to the shape of the foot for cushioning and a personalized fit
  • Leather upper material is easy to clean and maintain to extend product life
  • polyurethane outsole provides durable shock absorption to help reduce foot fatigue

4
Image
Dockers Mens Colleague Dress Penny Loafer Shoe, Black, 11 M Read Review

  • Polished man-made uppers
  • Easy slip on and off the foot loafer construction
  • Signature penny strap
  • Cushioned latex footbed for exceptional comfort
  • Durable rubber outsole

5
Image
Cole Haan Men's Pinch Penny Loafer, Black, 11 D US Read Review

  • Moccasin-toe penny loafer with stacked heel
  • Perforated footbed
  • sturdy heel

6
Image
Nunn Bush Men's Noah Penny Loafer Dress Casual Slip On Shoe, Brown, 10 Read Review

  • CLASSIC STYLE: Made with premium leather uppers with classic moccasin toe detailing give the Noah a polished look that looks great either dressed up with suits and dress pants, or dressed down with jeans and chinos.
  • COMFORT: Fully padded sock lining with Comfort Gel provides outstanding comfort right of the box. Can also be worn sockless.
  • PERFECT FIT: Available in medium width and wide width for the perfect fit.
  • OUTSOLE: Non-leather, long wearing man-made outsole
  • VALUE: Nunn Bush is highly regarded as a premier footwear brand by providing the best value and style in fine men's footwear since 1912.

7
Image
Sperry womens Seaport Penny Loafer, Blush, 7 US Read Review

  • A classic yet modern penny-keeper silhouette that can beeffortlessly dressed up or down
  • Premium leather uppers in a moccasin construction
  • Leather memory foam insole provides all-day comfort, with a flexible non-marking rubber outsole